← All insights

Insights · November 23, 2026

88% plan to shop small.

Will they find your business?

Shoppers want to shop small this season, and most will look for a business on Google first. Most small businesses have a Google profile. Far fewer keep it up to date.

Strategy Butler Insights placeholder image

Our view

Holiday intent only helps a business shoppers can find. Before Small Business Saturday, the most valuable marketing for many small businesses isn't a new campaign. It's making sure the places customers already look, starting with Google, show accurate hours, fresh photos, current products and recent reviews.

Key takeaways

  • 88% of U.S. consumers plan to shop at a small business this holiday season, the highest level since 2012, according to American Express.
  • 85% of small business owners have a Google Business Profile, but only 35% keep an active presence there, and just 21% of independent retailers do, according to BrightLocal.

American Express's 2026 Shop Small Impact Study, conducted by Teneo in September and released Nov. 12, found that 88% of U.S. consumers plan to shop at a small business this holiday season, the highest level since 2012. The study surveyed 1,008 U.S. adults and 503 small business owners and managers, and found that 70% of owners say holiday spending will affect their ability to grow next year. American Express founded Small Business Saturday and sponsors the study.

What the data shows

BrightLocal's 2026 Small Business Marketing Report shows where those shoppers are likely to look. It found that 71% of consumers used Google at some point in their most recent search for a local business, and 61% started there, on Google Search or Google Maps.

Owners are on Google, but most aren't actively managing it. In BrightLocal's survey of 1,002 U.S. owners of local businesses with 1 to 50 employees, 85% have a Google Business Profile, yet only 35% say they keep an active presence there, and 30% updated it in the past week. Independent retailers, the businesses Small Business Saturday matters most to, were lowest, at 21%. Asked for their top two sources of new customers, only 22% of owners named Google, behind word of mouth (35%), social media (33%) and AI tools (23%).

Being found comes before being chosen

A shopper who wants to support a local business still has to decide which one. For many, that decision starts with a search: who's nearby, who's open, what they carry and what other customers say. A profile with old hours, few photos or unanswered reviews can lose that shopper before they ever walk in.

This isn't a case that Google matters more than word of mouth or social media. For many small businesses, those are real and valuable sources of customers. But they often work together: a customer hears about a shop from a friend, then looks it up before visiting. BrightLocal notes that owners may credit the last thing a customer mentions, so the search step can go unseen.

Why the basics get missed

Most small business owners handle marketing themselves. BrightLocal found that 85% take primary responsibility for marketing decisions while running the business day to day, and that budget, complexity, lack of time and not seeing a clear return are common barriers to doing more. In that context, a profile that was set up once and left alone is understandable.

In our experience, the fix isn't more channels. It's a short list of basics, kept current in the places customers already look, so the marketing a business already does has somewhere accurate to land.

Four things to check before Small Business Saturday

1. Listings: hours, photos and products

Confirm your Google Business Profile shows accurate regular and holiday hours, current photos and the products or services you want to sell this season. Do the same on Apple Maps, Yelp and any other listing customers use in your area.

2. Reviews: recent, visible and answered

Ask happy customers for reviews, and respond to recent ones, positive and negative. Recent reviews and thoughtful replies show shoppers that the business is active and cares about its customers.

3. Discovery: what search and AI tools say

Search for your business the way a customer would, on Google, in Maps and in AI tools such as ChatGPT. Check that the name, address, hours and description are accurate, and correct anything that isn't at the source.

4. Website: easy to use on a phone

Open your website on a phone. Within a few seconds, a shopper should see what you sell, where you are, when you're open and how to reach you. If your holiday hours or offers aren't on the site, add them.

A one-hour checklist for this week

These steps apply whether marketing is handled by the owner, a staff member or an outside partner.

  • Update holiday hours. Add Thanksgiving week and Small Business Saturday hours to your Google Business Profile and website.

  • Add fresh photos. Post a few current photos of your storefront, products and team.

  • Post an update. Share what's happening on Nov. 28, such as an offer, event or new arrivals, as a Google Business Profile post.

  • Reply to reviews. Respond to any reviews from the past few months that haven't had a reply.

  • Ask for new reviews. Make it easy for regular customers to leave one, with a link or QR code at checkout.

  • Check your other listings. Make sure Apple Maps, Yelp and your social profiles match your Google details.

  • Search for yourself. Look up your business on Google and in an AI tool, and note anything inaccurate.

  • Set a reminder. Put a monthly check on the calendar so your profile stays current after the holidays.

Be easy to find

Shoppers want to support small businesses this season, and many will look them up before they visit. A little time on the basics can decide whether they find you or the business down the street. The right mix of channels depends on the business, but shoppers have to find you before they can choose you.

Questions to ask your team

  • Are our hours, including holiday hours, correct everywhere customers look?

  • When did we last update our Google Business Profile?

  • Are we responding to recent reviews?

  • What do search results and AI tools say about our business?

From Insight to Impact

Want a clear read on where your customers find you?

We help small and growing businesses see what's working and where to focus, from local search and listings to channel roles and budget, through a Channel Assessment or a Marketing Diagnostic. See what's included, and the sample work behind it.

Tell us about your businessSee what you get →

Sources

American Express: 2026 Shop Small Impact Study (conducted by Teneo; 1,008 U.S. adults and 503 small business owners and managers, September 2026; Nov. 12, 2026)BrightLocal: Small Business Marketing Report 2026, Chapter 1: Google (1,002 U.S. local business owners; Oct. 21, 2026)BrightLocal: Small Business Marketing Report 2026, Chapter 4: Who owns marketing (Oct. 21, 2026)

More Insights

All insights →
© 2026 Strategy Butler. All rights reserved.
strategybutler.com