Our view
Discounts can bring shoppers in, but they don't build trust on their own. When sales feel constant, shoppers look for other reasons to believe a brand: its reputation, clear pricing, easy returns and honest reviews. Those are earned across the year, not in a single week, and they matter for a local shop as much as a national brand. The right balance of promotion and brand building depends on the business, but discount depth alone is rarely what sets a brand apart.
Key takeaways
- Only 54% of consumers trust that advertised Black Friday prices are lower than normal, and about one in five actively distrust them, according to BCG's 2026 study of 10,220 consumers in 10 countries.
- Retailer reputation and money-back or free-return policies build the most trust, while influencer recommendations rank last, according to BCG.
- Salesforce expects U.S. discount rates to run 8% higher than last year in November.
BCG's sixth annual Year-End Sales Events Consumer Study, published Nov. 4, 2026, surveyed 10,220 consumers ages 18 to 75 across 10 markets, including the U.S., in September. Its central finding: shoppers still plan to buy, but fewer believe the deals.
What the data shows
Globally, 54% of consumers trust that advertised year-end prices are really lower than normal, and about one in five actively distrust them. U.S. shoppers are more trusting, at roughly two-thirds, while only about a third trust the deals in Germany, Denmark and the Czech Republic. And 22% plan to spend less or skip the sales altogether because they assume discounts are always available.
Retailers are moving the other way. Salesforce's Cyber Week forecast, published Nov. 19, expects November discount rates to run 5% higher than last year globally and 8% higher in the U.S. Deeper discounts and lower trust can exist at the same time, and that gap is where holiday budgets get wasted.
What builds trust, and what doesn't
BCG measured which factors make shoppers trust a deal more, net of those that make them trust it less. Retailer reputation and a money-back or free-returns policy scored highest, at 65% each, followed by verified purchase reviews (59%) and a clear comparison of regular and sale prices (58%). At the bottom were real-time scarcity messages like "only 3 left" (8%), AI-generated review summaries (4%) and influencer recommendations (3%).
The factors at the top are built over time. The ones at the bottom are tactics that can be switched on for a week. BCG also found that the minimum discount shoppers expect from a good deal slipped to about 30%, from 32% last year.
This isn't a case against promotions
Promotions have a job. They drive traffic, clear inventory and reward loyal customers, and for many businesses the holiday season is when that job matters most. The point is that discount depth alone isn't a durable advantage when every competitor is running a sale. What sets a brand apart is whether shoppers believe it.
In our experience, the brands that hold up best through the holidays treat the sale as one part of a longer relationship, with pricing, service and messaging that stay consistent before, during and after the event.
Four things to consider this week and beyond
1. Price clarity: make the deal easy to believe
Show the regular price next to the sale price, and keep discount logic consistent across your site, stores, email and ads. A shopper who can see what they're saving, and finds the same offer everywhere, has fewer reasons to doubt it.
2. Guarantees: lead with what lowers the risk
If you offer easy returns or a money-back guarantee, put it in your ads, emails and product pages, not just the fine print. It answers the question many shoppers are quietly asking: what if this isn't the deal it looks like?
3. Reviews: keep them real and visible
Ask buyers for verified reviews after purchase, show them where people make decisions, and respond to the critical ones. Real customer voices carry more weight than any sale banner.
4. Reputation: build it before the sale
Brand building, early access for loyal customers and consistent service across the year are what make a holiday offer credible. Judge that investment on the right measures and timelines, not only on what sells in a single week.
Additional considerations for Cyber Week
Two other shifts are worth keeping in mind as holiday results come in.
Your reported results may look stronger than your sales
Starting Nov. 12, Meta switched on a Pixel setting called "Measure conversions on customer devices" by default outside the EU and UK. It recovers some conversions that weren't reported before, so reported conversions and return on ad spend may rise without any change in actual sales, according to PPC Land. Compare platform-reported results with your own orders and last year's baseline, and judge the week on incremental sales, not on which dashboard shows the biggest number.
AI is shaping more of the path to purchase
Salesforce expects AI and agents to influence $75.8 billion, or 21%, of global Cyber Week online sales, and AI-driven traffic to retailer sites is up 104% year over year. BCG found that 56% of shoppers plan to use generative AI to shop this season, while social media as a source of shopping ideas fell 9 points to 46%. Shoppers trust AI most to compare prices across retailers (39%) and product features (37%), and only 7% trust it to make the purchase. AI comparison makes inconsistent pricing easier to spot, so clear, consistent product, price and promotion data matters more than ever.
Win the week by earning belief
Every retailer will have a sale this week. Shoppers will choose the ones they believe. Brands that pair a fair offer with a strong reputation, clear pricing and an easy return policy won't need the deepest discount to win, and they'll keep those customers long after Cyber Monday.
Questions to ask your team
Would a shopper believe our sale price is real?
Do our ads and product pages lead with what builds trust: reputation, guarantees and reviews?
Are we judging holiday results on our own sales data, not just platform reports?
Can AI tools find and compare our prices and products accurately?
From Insight to Impact
Want a clearer read on what's driving your holiday results?
We help brands separate real performance from reported performance and sharpen how their offers and messages earn trust, through a Performance Review or a Brand & Creative Messaging Review. See what's included, and the sample work behind it.
Sources
BCG: Annual Black Friday Survey Finds 1 in 5 Consumers Actively Distrust Advertised Discounts (Nov. 4, 2026)BCG: For Year-End Sales Events, Trust Is the New Currency (Year-End Sales Events Consumer Study 2026)Salesforce: Record Cyber Week Expected to Deliver $75.8B in AI-Driven Sales (Nov. 19, 2026)PPC Land: Meta Pixel will count more conversions from Nov 12 unless advertisers opt out (Oct. 27, 2026)

