← All insights

Insights · November 10, 2026

What a marketing agency audit should cover,

and how to run one fairly.

An agency audit isn't about catching anyone out. It's a structured check that the work, the team and the fees still match what your business needs.

Two people reviewing work on a laptop, one taking notes

Key takeaways

  • A marketing agency audit reviews strategy, team, fees, media, results and contract terms together.
  • The goal is a clear, shared view of what's working, not a case for switching agencies.
  • Run one before a renewal, after a drop in results, or when your business goals change.

Most agency relationships start with a clear brief and drift over time as teams change, scopes grow and goals move. A periodic audit brings them back into line, and good agencies tend to welcome it.

When to audit your agency

Ahead of a contract renewal or annual plan, after a sustained drop in results, when key people on the account change, or when your business strategy shifts and you're not sure the work has followed.

Six areas a complete agency audit covers

1. Strategy and brief

Whether the work still ladders up to current business goals, and whether the brief the agency works from is up to date.

2. Team and time

Who works on your account, how senior they are, and whether the hours billed match the team you were promised.

3. Fees and billing

How the agency is paid, what the fee includes, and any markups, rebates or technology fees outside it.

4. Media and spend

Where the budget goes and why, and whether the plan reflects your objectives rather than habit or partner incentives.

5. Results and reporting

Whether reports measure business outcomes, and whether you can check the numbers yourself.

6. Contract and data

Audit rights, data ownership, termination terms, and who owns the ad accounts, creative and tools.

What you should receive

A clear summary of what's working, what isn't and why, with prioritized recommendations: what to keep, what to change and what to raise with the agency. It should give both sides a shared, factual basis for the next conversation.

What it costs

Cost depends on scope, from a focused review of one media plan to a full review of strategy, fees and contracts. Ask for a fixed fee agreed in advance, and make sure the reviewer earns nothing from any agency or vendor they might recommend.

How Strategy Butler approaches it

Agency oversight and media plan reviews are part of our Advisor and Executive work. We review the plan, the team and the terms with no stake in which agency you use, and help you raise findings constructively so the relationship gets stronger. We don't buy media or take commissions.

Common questions

What is a marketing agency audit?

A structured review of an agency relationship, covering strategy, team, fees, media, results and contract terms, and ending with clear recommendations.

How often should you audit your agency?

At least once a year, ahead of planning or a renewal, and whenever results drop, key people change or your strategy shifts.

Will an audit damage the agency relationship?

Not if it's run fairly. Share the scope up front, focus on facts rather than blame, and treat the findings as a shared basis for better work.

Questions to ask your agency

  • Who works on our account, and how much of their time do we get?

  • What do we pay beyond the base fee, including markups, rebates and technology fees?

  • Can we access our ad accounts, data and reports directly?

  • How does each part of the plan connect to our business goals?

From Insight to Impact

Want an independent read on your agency?

We review plans, teams and terms with no stake in which agency you use, and help you turn the findings into better work.

Tell us about your businessWhy independent counsel →

More Insights

All insights →
© 2026 Strategy Butler. All rights reserved.
strategybutler.com